Enhancing Performance And Sustainability In Philanthropy – Research Report

Index

This brief index offers a guide to the structure and intent of this report, designed to provide philanthropic leaders and stakeholders with data-driven insights and practical recommendations for addressing the pressing challenges faced by today’s nonprofit organizations. The report delves into the nuances of nonprofit management, leadership dynamics, and strategies for overcoming obstacles. 

Research Approach and Participant Profile

This section outlines the research methods employed with eight senior philanthropic leaders from the core of this study.

Core Themes Identified

  • Burnout and Retention Challenges
  • Leadership Alignment and Resource Allocation
  • Communication and Cross-Departmental Coordination
  • High Expectations and Performance Pressure

Practical Solutions and Recommended Frameworks

This section of the report delves deeper into the identified core themes and explores potential solutions and frameworks to guide a leader’s thinking as it relates to the challenge facing the philanthropic sector today.

Wrap Up: Next Steps and Why This Report Matters

While the nonprofit landscape is often associated with limited budgets and high expectations, this report demonstrates that by implementing clear frameworks, fostering better communication, and aligning leadership goals, philanthropy leaders can enhance performance and sustainability. By addressing these core challenges, philanthropic organizations can create an environment that supports both mission-driven impact and employee well-being.

For a deeper dive into each finding and solution, read through the full report to unlock insights that could reshape the future of philanthropy and empower today’s leaders.


Executive Summary

This research report represents a cross-sector of organizations from across the nation and provides an analysis of the challenges faced by philanthropic leaders and offers actionable insights for increasing leadership effectiveness and feasibility to achieve identified targets. Through in-depth interviews with eight philanthropic leaders, key trends and patterns emerged that significantly impact organizational performance and sustainability.

Research Methodology:

This report is based on interviews conducted over a 3-week timespan with eight philanthropic leaders spanning a variety of sectors with annual fundraising targets ranging in size from $1M to $100m+ annually with 10+ employees within the organization. 

Fun Fact: Research doesn’t have to be hard. Jakob Nielsen and Tom Landauer found that you only need to test with 5 users in order to identify 75-99% of trends and usability issues. This report represents the thoughts and reflections from 8 philanthropic leaders, combined with ThriveLab’s extensive experience and insights.

The primary focus of the interview questions was on identification of trends and patterns related to barriers impacting optimal performance and sustainability within non-profit organizations. All respondent information is kept confidential but direct, anonymized quotes may be used throughout this report. 

Summary of Key Findings:

Burnout and high turnover rates are among the most pressing issues plaguing philanthropic leaders and organizations today, driven by immense pressure from both internal and external demands, compounded by resource constraints and inefficient productivity tools. This constant strain results in significant stress, leading to frequent employee turnover and diminished organizational effectiveness. While each organization faces unique challenges, philanthropic leaders can achieve the highest ROI in improving effectiveness and long-term impact by focusing on four key areas:

  • Employee Burnout – Burnout and high turnover rates are among the most pressing issues plaguing philanthropic leaders and organizations. Leaders and staff face immense pressure from both internal and external demands, amplified by resource constraints, being understaffed, lower compensation, inefficient productivity tools and demanding expectations exacerbated by unclear pathways for professional growth and development.
  • Misalignment and Inefficiency – A considerable challenge is misalignment within the senior leadership team. What often starts with a lack of understanding about the role and function of the philanthropic arm of an organization often descends into an inability to allocate resources effectively and prioritize efforts that will most move the needle. Organizations also often struggle to establish a unified and strategically identified path forward, resulting in confusion and inefficiency.
  • Communication Breakdown – Effective communication and collaboration are critical for success, yet many philanthropy leaders face challenges in these areas. Breakdown in communication within the organization, particularly between the philanthropy department and other departments or divisions hinders the ability to foster a collaborative environment with their peers within the organization leading to organizational silos and lack of shared information.
  • Performance Stress with High Expectations – Philanthropic leaders often face large, audacious targets with intense pressure to deliver results with insufficient support from marketing and top-level leadership. This intense pressure leaves philanthropic leaders feeling the paralyzing pressure of trying to hit big donation numbers without support or clear strategic direction. The performance stress is very real for philanthropy professionals as they navigate high expectations in a complex and oftentimes under-resourced environment.

Though these challenges can feel insurmountable when day-to-day responsibilities prohibit proactive problem solving, frameworks and processes can easily provide a path towards minimizing the effects of them.

Suggestions for remediation and next steps within each of these four areas are included in the Recommendations section of those areas below. 


Findings and Recommendations:

Employee Burnout & Turnover

Estimated Current SeverityEstimated Solution FeasibilityEstimated Solution Impact
HighMediumSignificant
  • The greatest impact is the number of organizations who are experiencing high levels of employee burnout and turnover. Overall, 7 out of 8 organizations experience high employee burnout and turnover as a primary concern.
  • 5 of 8 indicated burnout and turnover was due to low compensation packages.
  • And, 6 out of 8 indicated burnout was due to being under-resourced and lacking sufficient infrastructure.

“We are always under-resourced to get the job done effectively.”

“Recruitment and retention are always an ongoing challenge for us.”

Root Causes

  • Lack of a deep understanding amongst fundraising staff of the problems the organization aims to solve, leading to ineffective strategies and transactional philanthropy.
  • Organizations struggle with prioritizing key objectives, often juggling too many priorities without clear focus. There’s a pressing need to align resources with well-defined strategic priorities to enhance efficiency and impact.
  • There is not a consistently identified pathway to grow and train leaders to ensure organizational stability and continuity in the face of turnover.
  • The immense pressure of performance is held in tension with internal and external factors influencing giving.

Recommendations

“Burnout is a form of exhaustion caused by constantly feeling swamped. It happens when we experience too much emotional, physical, and mental fatigue for too long.” – WebMD

  • Establish and follow very clear strategic priorities
    • WHY: The reason people feel swamped is because they have more to get done than they are capable of doing in the available time. So we have to either give them less to do, better tools to do it faster, or more time to get it done. Clear strategic priorities empower leaders to focus on what matters most while trimming away the things that suck away time but have low impact. 
    • HOW: Strategic plans are best facilitated as a collaborative effort amongst an organization’s entire senior leadership team. However, they’re very easy to do wrong.  We recently wrote an article guiding you through a better strategic planning process.
  • Help team members connect to purpose in your mission
    • WHY: Every person holds a variety of purposes for their lives. If they can connect to their purpose as an individual, and see it clearly in how they contribute to your organization, their mentality shifts from seeing work as something they HAVE to do (externally motivated), to something they DESIRE to do (internally). That shift energizes instead of fatigues, and the burnout that accompanies fatigue fades with it. 
    • HOW: Ensure all employees have a deep understanding of the philanthropic organization’s purpose, mission and vision. Conduct regular sessions where leadership connects team efforts with real-world impact stories. Invite your team to the “front-lines” of the work showing them how their work contributes to change. You can also foster cross-departmental collaboration and create opportunities for staff to contribute ideas and receive feedback on mission-related initiatives. Consider integrating mission-driven workshops and discussions into team meetings, and implement performance metrics that evaluate both output and alignment with mission-driven objectives.
  • Invest in leadership development and training
    • WHY: High turnover, particularly in leadership, leads to organizational instability and negatively impacts long-term philanthropic efforts along with a loss of institutional knowledge and mission alignment. A lack of clear leadership pathways exacerbates this issue, contributing to ineffective outcomes and creating a barrier to sustained progress.
    • HOW: Create structured leadership development programs that offer mentoring, skill-building workshops, and clear pathways for career progression within the organization. Focus on nurturing both current and emerging leaders, preparing them to take on greater responsibilities while maintaining a cohesive, purpose-driven culture. Consider leveraging external partners or consultants to develop leadership programs focusing on both hard and soft skills required for philanthropy. Lastly, develop feedback loops where emerging leaders can give input into organizational strategy, fostering engagement and leadership growth.
  • Enhance recognition & appreciation activities 
    • WHY: Another strong contributor to the effects of burnout is feeling as if your work is futile. There’s a form of torture used in POW camps where the captors will force the captives to move big heavy rocks from one side of the yard to the other. The next day, they move them back again. Over and over again like this until people start to break. Sometimes our workplaces can start to feel this way, but recognizing individual or team efforts and intentionally offering gratitude helps people see why their work matters.
    • HOW: Implement personalized, purpose-driven recognition programs that align with the mission and purpose of the organization. You can also create peer-to-peer recognition programs or create non-monetary rewards aligned with individual preferences like extra time off, professional development opportunities or recognition in front of senior leadership. Use employee feedback to determine how they prefer to be appreciated. Integrate gratitude rituals and celebrate milestones and small wins frequently. Regular gratitude and recognition practices reinforce progress and keeps motivation high.

Misalignment Amongst Leadership Teams

Estimated Current SeverityEstimated Solution FeasibilityEstimated Solution Impact
HighMediumSignificant
  • Seven out of eight philanthropic leaders lacked time and accessibility to and with other senior-level leaders within the organization
  • Six out of eight organizations or development departments lack a strategic plan clearly outlining goals and outcomes for the next 3-5 years
  • And, six out of eight organizational leaders lacked a solid understanding of the role and impact of philanthropy and fundraising within their own organization

“I need to get senior leadership in front of the right people more often,
but the minutiae always gets in the way.”

“Philanthropy isn’t viewed as a revenue source – senior leadership is unclear 
about the overall purpose of philanthropy.”

Root Causes

  • Lack of clarity and understanding for the role of philanthropy within the organization. Many senior leaders lack an understanding of the importance, impact, and the donor life-cycle which leads to misalignment between the philanthropy team’s goals and objectives and the organization’s larger mission.
  • Misaligned resources and high expectations placed on philanthropy teams often co-exist. Having high expectations without providing the necessary resources both in terms of staffing and technological support leads to inefficiencies and burnout.
  • Philanthropy leaders often lack sufficient time and access to other senior-level leaders, preventing them from aligning goals, sharing insights, or solving strategic challenges and leveraging valuable human-resources and stories of impact.
  • Without a clear strategic plan, philanthropy teams struggle to focus on defined priorities, which results in confusion about where to allocate efforts and how to measure success.

Recommendations

“When there is no alignment, chaos reigns, and energy is wasted as people pull in different directions.”  –  Patrick Lencioni

  • Clearly align philanthropy’s role with the organizational strategy
    • WHY: Without a clear understanding and transparency of the role and impact of philanthropy within the organization, the organization risks undervaluing it as a revenue stream and strategic asset. This lack of alignment leads to conflicting priorities, inefficient resources allocation, and unclear expectations, further contributing to confusion and burnout.
    • HOW: Organize a leadership retreat or series of strategic alignment meetings to define philanthropy’s role within the overall mission and impact. Remember, you have an internal and external audience who must understand the role and impact of philanthropic endeavors. In these sessions, engage key stakeholders – including the CEO, board members, and philanthropy leadership. Articulate a shared vision for how philanthropy contributes to the organization’s goals. Develop a 1, 3 and 5 year strategic plan that outlines specific goals, outcomes, and key metrics to ensure everyone is on the same page regarding expectations and resource needs.
  • Establish a philanthropy leadership council for cross-departmental alignment
    • WHY: A significant root cause of misalignment is the lack of communication and collaboration between the philanthropy team and other senior leaders. When philanthropy leaders are not integrated into broader strategic discussions, it results in conflicting priorities, underappreciation of their contributions, and an inability to align efforts effectively with organizational goals. This gap contributes to inefficiency and burnout within the philanthropy team.
    • HOW: Create a Philanthropy Leadership Council that includes senior leaders from all key departments, with a specific focus on integrating philanthropy into the organization’s strategic planning. The council should meet regularly to ensure that philanthropy’s objectives are aligned with the overall mission and that resources are allocated appropriately. These meetings will serve as a platform for sharing updates, addressing cross-departmental challenges, and creating alignment on strategic priorities. By institutionalizing this council, philanthropy will gain a consistent voice at the leadership level, ensuring that its contributions are fully understood and valued across the organization.
  • Invest in strategic learning and resource optimization
    • WHY: Misalignment among leadership is oftentimes exacerbated by a lack of understanding of philanthropy’s role, the donor cycle and insufficient resources to support the team. This disconnect between expectations and capacity leads to inefficiency, confusion and burnout. Leaders must gain a clearer understanding of philanthropy’s organizational impact while equipping the team with the necessary tools and resources to meet strategic goals.
    • HOW: Begin by organization leadership workshops that focus on philanthropy’s role in the broader organizational mission, using data and case studies and donor stories to emphasize its financial and mission-driven impact. These workshops should engage all senior-level leaders, ensuring they understand how philanthropy drives long-term goals and how their departments can collaborate more effectively. Foster a culture of continuous learning, improvement and strategic clarity across the leadership team.

Communication Breakdown

Estimated Current SeverityEstimated Solution FeasibilityEstimated Solution Impact
MediumHighSignificant
  • Half of those interviewed identified a lack of clear communication channels within the organization, particularly related to organizational impact and the gathering of stories and narratives to support their philanthropic efforts.
  • Half of those interviewed indicated that the senior leadership team was working in silos, they lacked collaborative partnerships with finance, communications, marketing and other senior-level leadership.
  • Five out of eight individuals found that their teams had a difficult time understanding their purpose and how they support the organizational mission.

“Most of my team lacks the awareness of the problems they are really trying to help solve.”

“I worked tirelessly to get the senior leadership to trust the philanthropy team. 
It is an ongoing challenge.”

Root Causes

  • Trust is foundational for effective communication and collaboration. A lack of trust among senior leadership can be difficult and lead to siloed thinking, guarded communication, and reluctance to share resources and ideas.
  • When different departments operate in isolation, it hinders collaboration. Silos can cause misalignment between philanthropy and other departments (finance, marketing, communications, etc.), leading to inefficiency and disconnected strategies.
  • Lack of clear communication channels and mechanisms for sharing information across departments, teams struggle to align on goals and understand their purpose within the organization. 
  • Active listening and building cross-departmental relationships are critical leadership skills and without training and practice in these areas, leaders may unintentionally hinder internal collaboration and engagement.
  • Being disconnected from the purpose of the organization hinders the team’s understanding of their role in advancing the organization’s mission and weakens engagement and alignment across departments.
  • An “us vs. them” mentality can begin to undermine communication channels and teams struggle to find common language and come together with a mutual understanding of how to create alignment and overcome challenges and turn them into innovation.

Recommendations

“Communication works for those who work at it.” – John Powell

  • Be intentional about building trust within the organization
    • WHY: Trust is essential for collaboration. When senior leaders trust each other, they are more willing to share resources, ideas, and strategies that advance organizational goals.
    • HOW: Be intentional about investing in things such as offsite retreats, peer-to-peer coaching, and transparent communication forums. Establish meeting protocols that encourage leadership to openly share challenges and successes, fostering a culture of vulnerability and accountability.
  • Break down silos through structured cross-departmental collaboration
    • WHY: Individuals get busy, or become protective of information because information oftentimes equals power and status. Silos limit the flow of information and resources, preventing philanthropy teams from leveraging the full capacity of the organization. A more integrated approach enables philanthropy to align with organizational goals and enhance overall effectiveness.
    • HOW: Create cross-functional teams or task forces that involve members from philanthropy, finance, marketing and communications to work on joint initiatives. Regularly scheduled meetings with clear, shared goals can foster collaboration and create accountability. 
  • Clarify team roles in advancing organizational mission
    • WHY: When teams don’t understand their purpose, they feel disconnected from the mission, which diminishes engagement and alignment. Clarifying how each role contributes to the broader mission can re-energize and motivate teams. Also having clear roles and responsibilities empowers cross-collaboration and reduces silos.
    • HOW: Be intentional about creating opportunities for the team to reconnect with the organizational mission and understand how their specific roles and efforts contribute to achieving the mission. Use storytelling as a powerful way to illustrate the tangible impact and involvement of the various teams and the way they connect with and support the organizational mission. Senior leadership should clearly articulate these connections in team meetings.
  • “Collaborative Story Mapping” visual impact wall
    • WHY: A major challenge in organizations is the difficulty teams have in seeing their impact and purpose within the organizational mission. Storytelling is one of the most powerful ways to communicate impact, and creating a visual, real-time display of these stories can make the organization’s goals tangible and personal for each department.
    • HOW: Create a large, central “Collaborative Story Mapping” wall in a shared space where team members across all departments can contribute stories, photos, and data about their work and how it ties into the organization’s mission. These contributions could include stories from the field, donor success stories, fundraising highlights, and testimonials from beneficiaries. This wall will visually map how every department’s contributions moves the needle towards achieving the organization’s goals.

Performance Stress with High Expectations

Estimated Current SeverityEstimated Solution FeasibilityEstimated Solution Impact
HighHighSignificant
  • In the research, 5 out of 8 respondents acknowledged experiencing significant stress and tension related to consistently meeting fundraising targets. When the annual stressors and challenges were not immediate, many were already anticipating the pressure of an upcoming capital campaign. 
  • Additionally, 5 out of 8 respondents identified performance metrics and insufficient staff training as major obstacles that hindered both performance and their ability to manage performance-related stress.
  • Interestingly, only one respondent mentioned external factors, such as political and financial market volatility, as contributing to stress for those working in philanthropy.

“I know a campaign is coming, but I am not confident our processes are in place to hit the right marks and targets.”

“Individuals in the profession burn out quickly and often have a difficult time understanding their purpose within the organization.”

Root Causes

  • Philanthropic leaders are often tasked with meeting large, aspirational fundraising goals with inadequate support in both partnership with organizational leadership and staffing. This leaves philanthropy professionals feeling unsupported in their efforts to cultivate relationships and secure donations, leading to heightened stress.
  • A lack of clear strategic direction or alignment between leadership, fundraising teams, boards, and other departments, philanthropy professionals struggle to focus on the right targets, goals and objectives. The absence of a shared vision and priorities inhibits their pressure to perform, often leaving them feeling isolated in their efforts and challenged with understanding progress or success.
  • A common theme is the lack of investment in team capacity and training. Oftentimes philanthropy departments are understaffed, or mis-staffed meaning they have insufficient resources to fulfill the requirements of their job, leaving them with the need to do more with less, leading to feelings of overwhelm with burnout, especially when managing large campaigns.
  • Many philanthropic organizations rely heavily on traditional, annual performance metrics that don’t account for relationship-building, engagement efforts, or the longer lead times required to cultivate major and principal gifts. The pressure to meet rigid, sometimes unrealistic, short-term targets intensifies stress and undermines sustainable long-term growth.
  • Leaders often feel continuous pressure, not only from their current fundraising responsibilities but also from the consistent pressure of future capital campaigns. The constant cycle of ending one campaign and starting another leaves little room for rest and reflection, as they are always needing to anticipate the next big initiative.
  • Marketing and external communications often lags behind the fundraising efforts, creating a gap in donor engagement, stewardship and outreach.  This disconnect forces philanthropy professionals to carry the responsibilities of those tasks and leaves them challenged to balance the need to meet the identified metrics.
  • Poor communication between fundraising teams and leadership teams contributes to the stress as changes in strategic priorities can often shift leading to uncertainty and frustration about how to prioritize efforts and determine pathways to success.

Recommendations

“Success today requires the agility and drive to constantly rethink, reinvigorate, react, and reinvent.” –  Bill Gates, as quoted in Business Insider

  • Redefine Success Beyond Short-Term Metrics
    • WHY: Traditional fundraising metrics often focus narrowly on short-term financial results, which can create pressure without recognizing the long-term relationship-building necessary for sustained success. The reliance on rigid financial targets can overlook the value of donor cultivation, engagement, and stewardship over a longer period of time leading to less burnout and higher performance over time.
    • HOW: Shift the focus to a balanced scorecard that includes relationship metrics, donor retention rates, and engagement activities alongside broadened financial outcomes. Implementing more holistic metrics over a longer period of time allows organizations to celebrate progress in building strong donor relationships that will eventually lead to major gifts. Research suggests that organizations that adopt a broader set of performance measures experience higher morale, more sustainable donor growth, and reduced staff turnover.
  • Invest in Team Capacity and Professional Development
    • WHY: Insufficiently trained or understaffed teams are a major contributor to stress, as employees feel they lack the resources and knowledge to meet expectations. Continuous professional development including but in addition to the basics of fundraising practices ensures that fundraising staff are equipped with the skills needed to innovate and perform efficiently.
    • HOW: Allocate a portion of the annual budget specifically for staff training and hiring, focusing on areas like donor engagement, technology tools for fundraising, and strategic planning. This investment should also include leadership training for current managers to better support their teams and create a healthier work environment. Focusing on development and training experiences oftentimes produces increased engagement, professional confidence and better results.
  • Implement a “Donor Concierge” model to enhance engagement
    • WHY: Many fundraising teams lack the marketing and external engagement support they need to connect with donors in more personalized ways, which adds to their stress of performance. By creating a “Donor Concierge” role or service, the organization can provide high-level, individually tailored interactions and donor engagement opportunities with key donors, reducing the pressure on fundraisers to handle every donor touchpoint.
    • HOW: Drawing from best practices in the luxury retail and hospitality sectors, this model would assign dedicated staff to serve as donor concierges, managing donor interactions, personalizing experiences and enhancing stewardship efforts that align with levels or potential levels of giving. This approach frees up fundraisers to focus on strategy and relationship-building activities without having to manage every detail of donor engagement. Highly personalized service models lead to stronger relationships and increased loyalty, which could translate to better donor retention and larger gifts over time.

Other Opportunity Areas Observed

  • External Factors: there is a need to understand the external volatility and adaptation to changing circumstances that impact the profession of philanthropy and philanthropic goals.
  • Psychological Challenges: there is a need to address the stress and challenges associated with fundraising and equip professionals to stay with organizations for longer periods of time.
  • Team Dynamics: building strong teams, fostering collaboration, and enhancing communication within the organization is paramount to the team’s success.
  • Overlooking Organizational Culture: philanthropic leaders must focus on the development of organizational culture and strategy in order to create a more sustainable model of philanthropy.
  • Time Management: balancing competing priorities and effectively managing time was a challenge for many, hindering their ability to focus on high-impact activities.
  • Understanding of Philanthropy: there was a lack of understanding of the role and process of philanthropy within the organizations surveyed, leading to stress, burnout and resource allocation challenges.
  • Board Understanding and Engagement: the boards of many of the organizations had a lack of understanding of the comprehensive nature of philanthropy’s impact. Board members lacked knowledge and pathways of how to engage and support the philanthropic efforts of the organization.
  • Entrepreneurial Mindset: longevity in the field of philanthropy is going to require creativity and out-of-the-box thinking to solve big issues such as high turnover, burnout and a changing donor demographic.
  • Endurance: leaders in the field of philanthropy are going to have to learn modalities of endurance and equip themselves with the knowledge of resources which support a sustainable work-life balance while facing both internal and external pressures facing leaders in philanthropy.

Next Steps:

  1. If you’d like help pinpointing where misalignment is costing time, energy, and donor dollars, here’s an offer: join me for a complimentary 30-minute strategy session. Here’s a link to my calendar (I’m only accepting 3 sessions/month, and for a limited time)
  2. You can also reach out for a free assessment that helps you determine which areas in your organizational focus would have the greatest potential impact on your philanthropic efforts.

For additional information, email [email protected].