Recent Gallup research estimates ~$1.9 trillion in annual productivity loss due to employee engagement, with numbers ringing in at around:
- 34% engaged in their work
- 50% not engaged
- 16% actively disengaged
That’s two thirds of the average workforce either actively or unconsciously apathetic. Surprisingly, that same Gallup research indicates that today’s engagement numbers are BETTER than we’ve seen historically. For example, in 2000 engagement numbers were:
- 25% engaged in their work
- 57% not engaged
- 18% actively disengaged
So that strips away our ability to casually point at external factors like COVID, remote/hybrid work, or cultural/political unrest and think, “of course, this is why”. What those external events have done, though, is expose what was previously hidden, but always there. McKinsey research found that two-thirds of workers in the US have started thinking about their purpose in life because of COVID. That those may be the same two-thirds in both research findings is no coincidence. It’s not that people don’t want to work. People don’t want to work when their work has no meaning.
Apathy Can’t Coexist With Meaning
On what has probably been my favorite team to be a part of, our team’s purpose was to improve the lives of our fellow employees by designing a better workforce experience. Over the course of about a year and a half, project after project either got shelved or stripped down to its basest value. This was largely due to leadership shifts or resource allocation to more short-term outcomes.
And over the course of that year and a half I observed a highly-motivated, caring team descend into apathy. I descended as well. It became really hard to care when our work fell into the void – our purpose was being minimized over and over again.
Noticing this, we regrouped as a team and redefined our purpose, focusing on elements that were more in our control. With that purpose, meaning returned. And it was followed soon after by a resurgence in motivation and care for the work. To be clear, though, this was a team-level solution to a leadership-level issue. Motivation and care levels were never as high as when we had full leadership support for the team’s initial purpose.
Yet in that experience I got to see firsthand what cultures throughout history have found – meaning and apathy have an inverse relationship.
So Give Meaning
Helping a team or employee connect with meaning is complex because meaning is unique to each individual. Understanding this, you must start by decoding the pieces of each individual’s source of meaning (of which they themselves are often not aware), then put the pieces back together in a way that an entire team can find meaning in a collective purpose, vision, or goal.
Our source of meaning is found in values, so start there. Follow this process, and you’re well on your way to infusing care and motivation back into an apathetic team:
- Actively identify each individual’s values
- Using the commonalities in values and an understanding of the team’s work, collectively define a team purpose
- Align individual values to the purpose of each team / organization, expanding sub-purpose in areas where you are in control
- For example, a sub-purpose on my workforce experience team became ensuring that each team member grew a desired skill set in a tangible way
- Map connection-points between the team purpose and the mission/vision of the wider organization
- Empower team members with autonomy aligned to the team’s purpose
Combining each of these steps, you have a process leaders can follow for their own teams. Each step can be an elaborate undertaking in and of itself, though. So we’ll expand on how to build a framework using this process in future articles. Don’t let the difficulty of the process dissuade you, though. Your organization’s share of ~$1.9 trillion is at stake!

