My mind locked in. The screech of a tape measure and the scratch of a razor blade into soft sheetrock became a rhythmic soundtrack. An unforeseen challenge would arise, and be met with calm, structured plans toward solution. I was enraptured with my task, and lost to time as the hours ticked away. This was me, fully engaged in the task at hand. It wasn’t until the last screw was in place that I consciously acknowledged the outside world.
When was the last time you felt completely lost in an activity? When everything else melted away and your focus was fully committed to the thing in front of you? And what are the ingredients that made that experience possible? For me it’s always been:
- Care. I have to have some reason to want to be doing what I’m doing
- Challenge. I love figuring out a puzzle or solving a problem
- Discovery. I seek to expand my own perspective and learn something new
- Reward. That hit of dopamine I get when I look at something I’ve created, built, or crafted is like no other
By exploring that phenomenon of complete engagement in myself and researching it with others, I’ve found that it’s often some variation of those four things that are present. And while that level of absorption is rarely necessary (or even helpful) in our workplaces, those ingredients are still critically important in overall sentiments of engagement across a workforce.
And through them, we gain unique insight into why so many employers are experiencing low levels of engagement right now.
Something New Is Happening
As we explored in “An Antidote To Apathy”, a recent article on connecting to meaning at work to begin re-engaging employees, engagement numbers have been low for a really long time. Surprisingly, they’re better now than they were 25 years ago.
But it sure doesn’t feel that way. Almost every leader I talk to, across a wide variety of companies spanning from Amazon to startups, from GM to small agencies, reports a general sense of “meh” on their teams. And these are great leaders, who’ve built successful teams time and again throughout their career. Why?
Over the last 5 years, people in the U.S. have faced an unprecedented number of disruptive events. To name a few:
- COVID and the accompanying shift to remote work
- A growing political culture of divisiveness and violence
- Unsustainable cost of living increases
- The rise of AI
- A resurgence in interest in spiritual connection
- Race, gender, and sexual orientation inequities being spotlighted
When everything around someone is in disarray and the way that they’ve learned to survive and be safe are no longer correct, their relationship with each of those engagement ingredients changes. What worked before is no longer working.
Care
When tomorrow no longer feels guaranteed and the pressure of simply surviving gets stronger, people’s care tends to shift in one of three ways: (1) they care more about pleasure, thinking that at least they should enjoy right now (2) they adopt a “why bother” mentality, and care about little at all (3) they lose care for the things that are fleeting, and focus more on meaning, relationships, and experiences.
This means that the amount of care a person has for their job is most likely decreasing. Because work isn’t often pleasurable, it won’t stave off a “why bother” approach, and it’s somewhat fleeting.
Challenge
Resilience is a distinctly human trait. People thrive in overcoming adversity. But we also have limits. Adversity is draining and saps our energy for engagement. We’ve faced a lot of adversity in external events recently. So our appetite for challenge is diminished. We’re seeking a moment of peace to recharge and rebuild energy before we face the next challenge… but it’s not happening.
Discovery
When everything feels new, new loses its meaning. Since we’re already having to discover the new rules of the world in which we now live and what our place is in it, we’re in discovery overload. There’s so much new information coming in, we haven’t been able to figure out how to integrate and make sense of it. So discovery feels less satisfying. We are too overwhelmed to make the discovery stick.
Reward
The primary reward in work is money. Unfortunately, money does not hold close to the value it did a couple years ago. People would rather have their time. While more money would obviously help offset the rising cost of living stress, there’s often an imbalance between what an organization can offer employees, and what they deem worthwhile.
This is why it feels like employees are more disengaged right now. Now the question becomes, “what can we do about it”?
Try This Instead
While obviously improving just one ingredient will be helpful, combining little shifts in each of them will be more impactful. So start small with these steps:
Care – Draw the line connecting their job to one of the three things they care more about now. For example, continually remind them how much time this job gives them to spend with family. Or how the connections, locations, etc.. of this job are helping them experience more pleasure.
Challenge – Make the challenge smaller. Get to that state of overcoming the challenge faster to build feelings of momentum. Work with product management and UX professionals to break bigger challenges down into their smallest progressive pieces.
Discovery – Help your employees integrate discovery. Start with triage – help identify which discoveries aren’t as valuable, and focus on the ones that will be most helpful in their life. Then use frameworks attached to their work that provide support in integrating new knowledge.
Reward – Experiment with different types of rewards that you haven’t used before: time freedom, recognition, gratitude, connection, etc… . Observe the ones that appear to work best with each individual, and lean more into those.
It will take a little time and nuance to build your new engagement ingredients, but stick with it. Along the way, apply this same approach to discover your own engagement formula so you can reap the benefits as well!

